HomeConsumersAgentsPartnersInvestorsMarketplaceFAQ
4209 Old Banyan Way, Sanibel, FL 33957Active
4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 2
4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 3
4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 4
4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 5
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 6
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 7
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 8
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 9
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 10
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 11
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 12
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 13
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 14
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 15
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 16
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 17
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 18
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 19
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 20
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 21
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 22
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 23
  • 4209 Old Banyan Way, photo 24

4209 Old Banyan Way

Sanibel, FL 33957 · Single family

$999,000

Listing courtesy of Kelly Huguenin, Pfeifer Realty Group LLC

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 2,146 sqft

Cynthia's Insights On This Property

  • Built 1989 — before Florida's 2002 building code
  • Last recorded sale: $871,000 in January 2006
  • Typical sale in 33957 over the last year: $925,000, $562 per sq ft
  • Owners in 33957 stay about 8 years; 5% of homes changed hands last year
Get the free appSave homes, get alerts for new Sanibel listings and ask Cynthia anything.Open in the SURF LOCAL app
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

📊 Price Pulse

What would you pay for this place?

Sale prices come from county public records, not MLS data.

Listing agent

Kelly HugueninPfeifer Realty Group LLC

Contact

Send a message and we'll pass it to the listing agent. Nothing is sent until you ask.

About this home

Nestled within the highly sought-after Gulf Pines community, this charming 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of privacy, nature, and timeless Sanibel character. Tucked away among lush native vegetation, Gulf Pines is known for its peaceful setting, Old Florida feel, and spacious homesites—creating a true island retreat. Step inside and discover a comfortable and inviting layout designed for easy coastal living, with generous living spaces and a natural flow that makes both everyday living and entertaining a breeze. Whether you’re hosting friends or enjoying a quiet evening at home, this residence captures the relaxed elegance that defines life on Sanibel. Gulf Pines residents enjoy exclusive access to a beautifully maintained community clubhouse—perfect for gatherings and social events—Two swimming pools, as well as tennis for an active island lifestyle. Meandering paths wind through the neighborhood, leading you directly to one of Sanibel’s most breathtaking stretches of beach, where shelling, sunsets, and the soothing sound of the Gulf become part of your daily routine. Living here means embracing the very best of the Sanibel lifestyle—morning bike rides along scenic paths, afternoons on the beach, and evenings surrounded by nature’s beauty. If you’ve been searching for a home that offers both tranquility and connection to everything that makes Sanibel so special, this Gulf Pines gem is your opportunity to start Helping you live the sunshine you’ve been dreaming of!

moreless
Property type
Single family
Year built
1989
Lot size
0.36 acres
Garage
2 cars
On market
170 days
Price per sqft
$466
HOA fees
$152/mo
Listing ID
2260389
Show Full Details

Property Info

Property Type
Residential
Property Subtype
SingleFamilyResidence
Year Built
1989
District
West End
Neighborhood
Gulf Pines
Subdivision
Gulf Pines 2 Unred
Lot Size (acres)
0.36
On Market Date
2026-04-15
Cumulative Days on Market
170

Interior Features

Interior Features
Central Vacuum, Cathedral Ceiling(S), Breakfast Bar, Eat-In Kitchen, Double Vanity, Master Downstairs, Storage
Flooring
Carpet, Tile, Wood
Laundry Features
Laundry Room, Sink
Door Features
Sliding Doors

Appliances

Appliances
Dishwasher, Disposal, Microwave, Water Heater, Electric Range, Ice Maker, Washer/Dryer Stacked, Refrigerator

Heating & Cooling

Heating
Central
Cooling
Central Air, Ceiling Fan(S), Zoned

Exterior Features

Patio & Porch Features
Porch, Screened
Construction Materials
Frame, Vinyl Siding, Wood Siding
Roof
Fiberglass
Waterfront Features
Beach Access

Features & Amenities

Garage Spaces
2.0
Garage
Yes
Parking Features
Garage Door Opener
Security Features
Smoke Detector(S)
Lot Features
Wooded, Cul-De-Sac, Irregular Lot

Community/Association

HOA
Yes
HOA Fee
$1,825
HOA Fee Frequency
Annually
Community Features
Pool, Tennis Court(S), Clubhouse

Utilities

Sewer
Public Sewer
Water Source
Public

Taxes

Annual Tax Amount
$9,547
Tax Year
$2,025
Legal Description
GULF PINES 2 UNREC OR 912 PG 756 LOT 24

Other

Derived Previous List Price
$1,195,000

Data freshness

SURF LOCAL last checked
Nov 22, 2026, 12:26 PM EST

Location

Approximate location, shown from the displayed address.

Similar homes nearby

What Sold Nearby

  • $805,000220 Palm Lake DrSanibel, FL · Sold 2026-10-30
  • $800,0005657 Baltusrol CtSanibel, FL · Sold 2026-10-29
  • $760,0009247 Dimmick DrSanibel, FL · Sold 2026-10-23
  • $1,250,000824 Birdie View PtSanibel, FL · Sold 2026-10-23
  • $990,0001270 Par View DrSanibel, FL · Sold 2026-10-22
  • $1,410,0001901 Sanibel Bayou RdSanibel, FL · Sold 2026-10-15
  • $2,442,0001114 Seagrape LnSanibel, FL · Sold 2026-10-09
  • $1,450,000419 Lighthouse WaySanibel, FL · Sold 2026-10-08
Sale prices come from county public records, not MLS data.

Flood

Flood zone AE · 100-year floodplain

Flood data: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer.

What's Nearby

Restaurants
  • 400 Rabbits975 Rabbit Road, Sanibel, FL 33957, United States of America
    1.4 mi
Schools
  • Sanibel SchoolSanibel-Captiva Road, Sanibel, FL 33957, United States of America
    1.0 mi
Parks
  • Sanibel Recreation CenterSanibel, Florida, United States of America
    0.9 mi
Places data by Geoapify, © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Homes for sale near Sanibel

Data courtesy of: Sanibel & Captiva Islands Association of REALTORSDisclaimers and data details

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. ©2026 Sanibel & Captiva Islands Association of REALTORS, all rights reserved.

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Florida Realty

Broker: Craig Dorfman

Listing last updated: Nov 6, 2026, 11:50 AM EST. SURF LOCAL last checked: Nov 22, 2026, 12:26 PM EST.

Equal Housing Opportunity

SURF LOCAL is committed to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity. We do not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin.