Under Contract



516 Elizabeth St
Key West, FL 33040 · Single family
$1,890,000
Listing courtesy of Ellen Gvili, Ocean Sotheby's International Realty
- 2 Beds
- 3 Baths
Cynthia's Insights On This Property
- Built 1933 — before Florida's 2002 building code
- Last recorded sale: $890,000 in February 2021
- Typical sale in 33040 over the last year: $1,000,000, $825 per sq ft
- Owners in 33040 stay about 8 years; 4% of homes changed hands last year
📊 Price Pulse
What would you pay for this place?
Sale prices come from county public records, not MLS data.Listing agent
Contact
Send a message and we'll pass it to the listing agent. Nothing is sent until you ask.
About this home
Nestled in the heart of Old Town Key West, this historic gem boasts an impeccable blend of classic architecture and modern amenities. With a rich history dating back to the late1800's, this captivating residence offers the perfect opportunity to own a piece of Key West's storied past. Awarded the Gold Star for Historic Preservations, 516 Elizabeth St. is the perfect example of a Classical Revival Eyebrow House - a style unique to Key West. The roof overhangs over the second floor windows onto classic porch columns giving the suggested appearance of 'eyebrows' providing protection from rain and sun allowing the inside to have fresh air even during the hot summer months. Upon entering the home, original Dade County pine walls, high 10ft ceilings, original double hung wooden windows exude the timeless elegance of a bygone era. While preserving its historic character, this home has been thoughtfully updated with modern amenities. The kitchen features custom wooden cabinets and stainless steel appliances and all bathrooms are beautifully renovated. Enjoy the convenience of contemporary living without compromising on the historic appeal. The primary bedroom and bathroom upstairs provide a tranquil retreat, and the guest bedroom downstairs with it's own bathroom is convenient and comfortable. French doors lead from the formal dining room and kitchen to a sundeck with a covered dining area and extra lounging space to entertain. A Pool with water feature and new decking was just added to the property. This home has a rich history, with tales of past occupants, the Pinder family, and the unique stories of its heritage adding an extra layer of prestige and historical significance to its charm. This historic home is a rare find in a prime location, offering the best of both worlds. The house has some monthly vacation rental history and is sold furnished (some personal pieces & all art work excluded)!
moreless
- Property type
- Single family
- Year built
- 1933
- Lot size
- 1,983 sqft
- On market
- 40 days
- Listing ID
- 621199
Show Full Details
Property Info
- Property Type
- Residential
- Property Subtype
- SingleFamilyResidence
- Year Built
- 1933
- Neighborhood
- Old Town
- Lot Size (sqft)
- 1983.0
- Contract Date
- 2026-09-02
- On Market Date
- 2026-09-03
Interior Features
- Interior Features
- Entrance Foyer, Storage
- Flooring
- Tile, Wood
- Laundry Features
- Laundry Room
Appliances
- Appliances
- Washer, Dryer, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Range, Oven, Wine Cooler, Stainless Steel Appliance(S)
Heating & Cooling
- Heating
- Central
- Cooling
- Central Air, Ceiling Fan(S)
Exterior Features
- Patio & Porch Features
- Deck
- Construction Materials
- Frame
- Roof
- Metal
- Fencing
- Fenced
- Other Structures
- Shed(S)
- Private Pool
- Yes
Taxes
- Annual Tax Amount
- $12,246
- Tax Year
- $2,025
- Legal Description
- KW PT LOTS 1&2 SQR 49 H1-236 OR518-883 OR685-470/71 OR696-172/73 OR1075-2202 OR1164-1556/57 OR1293-2467/69 OR2948-0831 O
Data freshness
- SURF LOCAL last checked
- Nov 21, 2026, 2:14 PM EST
Location
Approximate location, shown from the displayed address.
Similar homes nearby
$1,775,000513 Truman Ave, Key West, FL 330402 Beds4 Baths2,604 sqftListing courtesy of Preferred Properties (KW) · Data courtesy of: Key West Association of REALTORS $1,749,0001719 Laird St, Key West, FL 330404 Beds3 Baths2,276 sqftListing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Knight & Gardner Realty · Data courtesy of: Key West Association of REALTORS $1,850,000530 White St, Key West, FL 330405 Beds3 Baths2,146 sqftListing courtesy of Ocean Sotheby's International Realty · Data courtesy of: Key West Association of REALTORS $1,898,000421 United St, Key West, FL 330403 Beds3 Baths2,205 sqftListing courtesy of Engel & Voelkers Key West · Data courtesy of: Key West Association of REALTORS $1,700,0001800 Atlantic Blvd #327C, Key West, FL 330402 Beds2 Baths1,311 sqftListing courtesy of Coastal Collection Real Estate Inc. · Data courtesy of: Key West Association of REALTORS $2,099,0001609 United St, Key West, FL 330406 Beds5 Baths2,570 sqftListing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Knight & Gardner Realty · Data courtesy of: Key West Association of REALTORS $1,950,000000 Old Town St, Key West, FL 330401 BathListing courtesy of Island Life Realty Experts · Data courtesy of: Florida Keys Board of REALTORS $2,150,0001419 Reynolds St, Key West, FL 330402 Beds2 Baths1,457 sqftListing courtesy of Brenda Donnelly Real Estate LLC · Data courtesy of: Key West Association of REALTORS
What Sold Nearby
$2,325,0002623 Gulfview DrKey West, FL · Sold 2026-10-30
$1,125,000927 Thomas StKey West, FL · Sold 2026-10-30
$960,0001800 Atlantic BlvdKey West, FL · Sold 2026-10-29
$1,000,000418 Amelia StKey West, FL · Sold 2026-10-26
$659,0002804 Harris AveKey West, FL · Sold 2026-10-26
$650,0001425 Eliza StKey West, FL · Sold 2026-10-23
$1,995,000419 Simonton StKey West, FL · Sold 2026-10-23
$600,000101 Golf Club DrKey West, FL · Sold 2026-10-23
Flood
Flood zone X · Minimal flood risk
What's Nearby
Restaurants
- The Café VeggieSouthard Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.2 mi
- Antonia'sMoe's Way, Key West, FL 33041, United States of America0.2 mi
- Havana Key West703 Duval Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.2 mi
- Only Wood Grill725 Caroline Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.2 mi
- Alonzo’s Oyster Bar700 Front Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.4 mi
- Island Dogs Bar505 Front Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.4 mi
- Louie's Backyard700 Waddell Avenue, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.8 mi
- Pizza Hut2300 North Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America1.4 mi
Groceries
- FaustosFleming Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.1 mi
- Olivia Street Grocery800 Olivia Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.3 mi
- Fausto's Food PalaceWhite Street, Key West, FL 33041, United States of America0.6 mi
- Gordon Food Service StoreNorth Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America1.6 mi
Schools
- Mary Immaculate Star of the Sea SchoolWindsor Lane, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.4 mi
- Reynolds SchoolReynolds Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.7 mi
- Montessori Children's SchoolVarela Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.7 mi
- Mary Sands Alternative SchoolDuncan Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.9 mi
- Horace O'Bryant Middle SchoolNorth Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.9 mi
- Key West High SchoolFlagler Avenue, Key West, FL 33041, United States of America1.5 mi
Parks
- Bill Butler ParkKey West, FL 33040, United States of America0.2 mi
- Gato Village Pocket Park616, Old Town, Key West, Florida, United States of America0.6 mi
- Truman Waterfront Park AmphitheaterKey West, Florida, United States of America0.7 mi
- Bayview ParkMidtown, Key West, Florida, United States of America0.7 mi
- Key West, FL 33040United States of America0.7 mi
- Old TownKey West, Florida, United States of America0.8 mi
- Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park601, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.9 mi
- Indigenous ParkMidtown, Key West, Florida, United States of America1.1 mi
Coffee
- Funky Rooster Coffee House & Wine Bar713 Caroline Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.2 mi
- Tropical DrinksDuval Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.4 mi
- The Baklava411 Greene Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.4 mi
- Cafe Maton500C Truman Avenue, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.4 mi
- Island Juice BarWall Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.4 mi
- CafelitoCatherine Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.5 mi
- Smoothie ShuttleDuval Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.6 mi
- StarbucksDuval Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America0.7 mi
More homes in Key West
Homes for sale near Key West
Data courtesy of: Florida Keys Board of REALTORSDisclaimers and data details
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Copyright 2026 Florida Keys Board of REALTORS®, Inc.
Continental Real Estate Group, Inc
Broker: Derek Eisenberg
Listing last updated: Nov 20, 2026, 5:28 PM EST. SURF LOCAL last checked: Nov 21, 2026, 2:14 PM EST.




























