HomeConsumersAgentsPartnersInvestorsMarketplaceFAQ
2503 Fogarty Ave, Key West, FL 33040Active
2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 2
2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 3
2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 4
2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 5
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 6
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 7
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 8
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 9
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 10
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 11
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 12
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 13
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 14
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 15
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 16
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 17
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 18
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 19
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 20
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 21
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 22
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 23
  • 2503 Fogarty Ave, photo 24

2503 Fogarty Ave

Key West, FL 33040 · Multi Family

$1,350,000

Listing courtesy of Key West Sisters, Preferred Properties (KW)

  • 5 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 1,950 sqft

Cynthia's Insights On This Property

  • Built 1943 — before Florida's 2002 building code
  • Last recorded sale: $908,000 in September 2020
  • Typical sale in 33040 over the last year: $1,000,000, $829 per sq ft
  • Owners in 33040 stay about 8 years; 4% of homes changed hands last year
  • County record lists a private pool
Get the free appSave homes, get alerts for new Key West listings and ask Cynthia anything.Open in the SURF LOCAL app
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

📊 Price Pulse

What would you pay for this place?

Sale prices come from county public records, not MLS data.

Listing agent

Key West SistersPreferred Properties (KW)

Contact

Send a message and we'll pass it to the listing agent. Nothing is sent until you ask.

About this home

Tropical Living Meets Investment Opportunity in the Heart of Key West!Welcome to 2503 Fogarty Avenue, a charming income producing multi unit property tucked behind a classic white picket fence. Offering a total of 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms across two separate residences, this versatile property combines modern comforts, tropical outdoor living and exceptional investment potential.The front residence features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, beginning with a covered front porch perfect for morning coffee or relaxing. Inside high ceilings create a bright airy atmosphere while the updated kitchen features granite countertops, white cabinetry and a gas range. Additional conveniences include an in unit washer and dryer, along with separate water and electric meters.Privately situated at the rear of the property, the spacious 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom residence is a true tropical retreat. Step outside into your own lush backyard oasis where mature mango and banana trees surround a large in ground concrete swimming pool. A generous lanai provides the perfect setting for alfresco dining, entertaining guests, or simply enjoying the Key West lifestyle. This residence also features a full kitchen, washer and dryer, and impact-resistant windows and doors.Adding even more versatility is a newly renovated bonus unit along the side of the home, complete with a private teak outdoor patio, an inviting space offering additional flexibility and privacy.Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio, enjoy multigenerational living or occupy one residence while generating rental income from the others, 2503 Fogarty Avenue offers an outstanding opportunity to own an exceptional Key West property!

moreless
Property type
Multi Family
Year built
1943
Lot size
5,000 sqft
Price per sqft
$692
Listing ID
622007
Show Full Details

Property Info

Property Type
ResidentialIncome
Property Subtype
MultiFamily
Year Built
1943
Neighborhood
Midtown East
Subdivision
Key West Realty Co
Lot Size (sqft)
5000.0
On Market Date
2026-11-09

Interior Features

Flooring
Tile

Appliances

Appliances
Washer, Microwave, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Dryer

Heating & Cooling

Cooling
Central Air, Ceiling Fan(S)

Exterior Features

Exterior Features
Outdoor Shower, Lighting, Rain Gutters
Patio & Porch Features
Deck
Construction Materials
Frame
Roof
Metal
Pool Features
Outdoor Pool, In Ground
Private Pool
Yes

Utilities

Sewer
Public Sewer

Taxes

Annual Tax Amount
$8,468
Tax Year
$2,025
Legal Description
Kw Kw Realty Cos First Sub Pb1-43 Lot 2 Sqr 43 Tr 21 Or265-379/80 Or558-861 Or720-472D/C Or720-464/65 Or763-1245 Or976-2

Data freshness

SURF LOCAL last checked
Nov 21, 2026, 11:20 PM EST

Location

Approximate location, shown from the displayed address.

Similar homes nearby

Flood

Flood zone AE · 100-year floodplain

Flood data: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer.

What's Nearby

Restaurants
  • Pizza Hut2300 North Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.2 mi
  • Goldman's Deli2796 North Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.3 mi
  • Palm Haven Restaurant3990 South Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.5 mi
  • Louie's Backyard700 Waddell Avenue, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.5 mi
  • Only Wood Grill725 Caroline Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.6 mi
  • Antonia'sMoe's Way, Key West, FL 33041, United States of America
    1.7 mi
  • The Café VeggieSouthard Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.7 mi
  • Alonzo’s Oyster Bar700 Front Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.8 mi
Groceries
  • Gordon Food Service StoreNorth Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.1 mi
  • Winn-Dixie2778 North Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.3 mi
  • Publix1112 Key Plaza, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.4 mi
  • Atlantic GroceryFlagler Avenue, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.6 mi
  • Publix3316 North Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.9 mi
  • Fausto's Food PalaceWhite Street, Key West, FL 33041, United States of America
    1.0 mi
  • Olivia Street Grocery800 Olivia Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.4 mi
  • FaustosFleming Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.7 mi
Schools
  • Key West High SchoolFlagler Avenue, Key West, FL 33041, United States of America
    0.5 mi
  • Poinciana Elementary SchoolDuck Avenue, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.6 mi
  • Horace O'Bryant Middle SchoolNorth Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.7 mi
  • Mary Sands Alternative SchoolDuncan Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.9 mi
  • Montessori Children's SchoolVarela Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.1 mi
  • Sigsbee Charter Elementary SchoolDewey Road, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.2 mi
  • Reynolds SchoolReynolds Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.3 mi
  • Mary Immaculate Star of the Sea SchoolWindsor Lane, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.5 mi
Parks
  • Smathers BeachNew Town, Key West, Florida, United States of America
    0.7 mi
  • Little Hamaca ParkNew Town, Key West, Florida, United States of America
    0.8 mi
  • Bayview ParkMidtown, Key West, Florida, United States of America
    0.9 mi
  • Alvin Frasier III Memorial ParkNew Town, Key West, Florida, United States of America
    1.2 mi
  • Monroe County Parks & BeachesNew Town, Key West, Florida, United States of America
    1.4 mi
  • Bill Butler ParkKey West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.5 mi
  • Gato Village Pocket Park616, Old Town, Key West, Florida, United States of America
    1.5 mi
  • Key West Tropical Forest & Botanical Garden5210, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.8 mi
Coffee
  • Riviera Coffee & Sandwich ShopKennedy Drive, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    0.6 mi
  • CafelitoCatherine Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.6 mi
  • StarbucksDuval Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.7 mi
  • Smoothie ShuttleDuval Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.7 mi
  • Cafe Maton500C Truman Avenue, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.7 mi
  • Tropical DrinksDuval Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.7 mi
  • Funky Rooster Coffee House & Wine Bar713 Caroline Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.7 mi
  • Ana's Café Cubano531 Greene Street, Key West, FL 33040, United States of America
    1.8 mi
Places data by Geoapify, © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Homes for sale near Key West

Data courtesy of: Key West Association of REALTORSDisclaimers and data details

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of The Key West Association of REALTORS®. MLS Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than this broker are marked with the MLS logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker’s office. The properties displayed may not be all of the properties in the MLS’s database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Properties listed by Brokers other than this Broker are marked with either the listing Broker’s logo or name or the MLS name or a logo provided by the MLS. Detailed information about such properties includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. The Florida Association of Realtors and its cooperating MLSs do not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright ©2026 The Key West Association of REALTORS®. All Rights Reserved.

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Keys Real Estate - Knight & Gardner Realty

Broker: Will Langley

Listing last updated: Nov 9, 2026, 2:38 PM EST. SURF LOCAL last checked: Nov 21, 2026, 11:20 PM EST.

Equal Housing Opportunity

SURF LOCAL is committed to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity. We do not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin.